Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Mark Diacono's avatar

I think we should all go and sit in the road after scrapes and await rescuing

Lyall Guiney's avatar

Hi Kate, first comment here, but I've been reading your pieces for a few months after finding your Substack via a community biodiversity group I'm in (over here in Ireland). I feel all of what you wrote there. We're in a quiet estate in a village on the outskirts of Dublin. Many lovely little gardens, but you know the type - precise, curated, cut and restrained. And a few wild-looking ones like mine that are generally agreed by the majority to be messy and making the estate look bad. Those of us with wild gardens advocate for leaving some of the green area at the top of the estate go wild. It is a battle for every inch there. Entrenched tradition and the fear of long grass being too difficult to cut trumps any concern about starving pollinators. People don't know AND don't care, and sometimes even seem proud of their own ignorance. Bemusing. I try to engage on the local level, listen to all concerns, and all the while nag constantly about how preserving nature is so important. We might gain an inch or two. But even at that I am always on the lookout for the estate mower coming out in case the "wild area" gets conveniently forgotten about and gets shredded. God. It is draining.

And having spent the last few years trying to bring life into my back garden and digging up half the concrete of the "front yard" to make it into an actual front garden, and watching neighbours go in the exact opposite direction, I too might be faced with having to move soon. It's so hard to let go of a sanctuary where wildlife is treated as a co-habitant in a world where "human first" is the default mode of almost everyone everywhere. Yes of course, many people "care about climate change" and might even give "biodiversity loss" a polite nod, but if it jeopardises "human first" then suddenly the the reaction changes. "Well the kids have to have space to play" ... "of course, but they never use that section, and look at all the bees flitting between the wildflowers that have poked their heads up" ... "ah don't worry about the bees, sure there'll go somewhere else and the neighbours will only be complaining that it looks messy". And so after a wonderfully peaceful five weeks of "No Mow May" suddenly dozens and dozens of bees lost nine-tenths of their food source in our estate, because the green area must look tidy and gardens must be paved for convenience.

Sorry, just moaning about my own situation. :-) But I wonder how many times the same conversation is being had all around the world, the same struggle for nature first, the same obliviousness of the ecological debt that humans owe. Anyway I just want to say that I feel all the same aspects of the grief and loss that you feel. You did what you could and change is inevitable. I hope you find peace again in your new home.

50 more comments...

No posts

Ready for more?